Welcome, Anonymous  •  Sign In  •  Register  •  Help

Reviews: Troy - The Director's Cut [Blu-ray]

» Equipment » Blu-ray Movies » Warner Home Video »

Troy - The Director
Troy - The Director's Cut [Blu-ray]
Other products by Warner Home Video
3.5 (832 reviews)
Buy from Amazon
Amazon Pricing and Availability*
As of: 2009-06-05
List Price: $34.99
Lowest New Price: $15.75
Lowest Used Price: $11.88

* Price is accurate as of the date/time indicated. Prices and product availability are subject to change. Any price displayed on the Amazon web site at the time of purchase will govern the sale of this product.
4The Best but has Big Mistake
4Brilliant And Sadly Lacking in Scope
41%Better On Blu-ray
50%Totally worth it even if you own the regular version
10%What a Mess
41%The human side is the key of this handsomely mounted motion picture...
40%Good
21%Why didn't W. Petersen...
50%Troy
5Troy ounce a pound
51%Top 10 Blue Ray Disc So Far!
40%An adaptation
5Historical Epic
5for greek mithology lovers
40%Troy
41%educational standpoint
51%"The Iliad" is not the only version of the Trojan War!
5Great Acting - Great Scenes - Great Dialogue
20%directors cut RUINED the troy experience for me!!!
51%No real Achilles' Heel
31%Should have theatrical Version!
41%Can someone show me where this is titled The Iliad and not Troy?
5Epic and Awesome
21%Peterson Cannot Grasp Homer
31%Homer disappears for this spectacle
20%TROY
4Pitt Rules
41%Petersen's majestic Troy
51%GREAT MOVIE!!
51%Brad Pitt as Terminator
40%Good Action
50%Loved it!
51%You have to get it
41%TROY!!!!!! An Amazing Journey
30%Director's Cut: It looks, sounds, and IS better
50%Troy
31%A Flawed But Worthy "Troy"
50%A Good Movie Made Great!!
41%Some thoughts:
20%Different Musical Score!
51%Directors should have final say!
40%Good movie
41%Achille's vs Troy
31%Entertaining enough
51%EPICS CAN STILL BE MADE
40%Troy on HDDVD .......Wow!!!!!!
51%Great Epic - Must See for Men
51%Troy - Director's Cut
41%Troy
51%Incredible movie!
51%Teacher used this to culminate Greek Mythology Unit
51%great cut and movie!
51%Loved It !!!!
41%Best fight scene in tradition of Ray Harryhausen's Sinbad movies
51%a masterpiece of perfection
51%Excellent Movie!
41%Hollywood's Enormous Trojan War Looks Amazing on Blu-Ray
30%Okay for what it is...
41%Great action movie
40%It definitely brings the movie up
51%Just watched the extended version
51%great epic
51%Achilles vs. Hector makes this one worth watching.
4Troy - Director's Cut (Ultimate Collector's Edition)
41%Awesome Collector's item... lame Director's Cut
51%best version of troy
5Do Not Believe the Negative
41%At last, now available in epic cut
51%I'm glad I bought this one
51%Take it, it's yours
5One of the greatest
50%HD REVIEW
50%Blu ray discs
50%Troy
21%I prefer the original cut...
4Well done movie.....but nothing outstanding
51%Rippling Passion
10%It sucks! Need I say more?
5Another Great Sword Epic.
5Shake them Haters Off!!
5My Favourite Blu-Ray So Far
51%Blu-Ray, Amazon, and Troy = Amazing!
5Amazing entertainment
4Achilles looks even better kicking butt
5despite what everyone else says...
4A better epic than "Alexander". An almost great film!
4Blu-Ray Troy is a... Joy. =)
51%Indeed, Ultimate Edition
4Troy in High Def. What more can you ask for?
5BETTER VERSION!
11%A Mule in Horse Harness...
3Musical score downgraded
51%The Best High Def Picture Yet
5Box Set
51%One of the best screenplays ever
41%A superior cut of a solid film.
5A Rich Masterpiece
51%Is this the movie Troy?
51%wow...just WOW!
4A Cut Above Your Everyday Epic
31%Arg!! angry
30%It's fine...but not great.
5Way better than the original
51%What Blu-ray is about!
3Another Grower
5Troy Directors cut
50%TROY The Ultimate Collector's Edition.
5great movie, cool new menu style
30%The Original Was Better
41%BETTER THAN THE THEATRICAL RELEASE
51%Well worth the investment
41%Much Better in HD
5Troy-Blu Ray
41%A must buy movie on blu-ray it mindblowing
5Troy Directors Cut
41%I gave it a chance, you should do the same
5Very long, but worth it
51%Worth It for the Troy Fan
10%Why?
5Directors Cut long but superb
4Great movie with excellent video transfer
51%Marvelous Edition!
51%Troy HD DVD
51%Troy Directors Cut
30%An improvement
51%Most stunning hd dvd
51%Well Worth Your Money
20%I can see why certain things were cut.
41%Director's cut improves on the original...worth the $ 14.99 price tag!
10%Disappointing--Don't waste your money getting this on Blu-Ray!
41%Great improvement
2Changed music?
51%Great Director's Cut - Great Widescreen Blu-Ray
3Correction
51%Nice set
51%Bigger and Badder than the Original
51%OUTSTANDING PICTURE AND SOUND!
10%Blu-Ray but NOT the original WIDESCREEN
51%The Most Beautiful DVD Box Set I've Ever Seen
51%Even better and more breathtaking than the theatrical - good to see Warner catching up on Blu-ray
51%Offsetting a bogus review with a 5 star rating
30%Verhoeven should have directed this
50%Enough is Enough
10%One star for Brad Pitt's rear end
20%This goddess can't sing
51%Fantastic Director's Cut
10%Seriously... why?
40%Pitt tried
10%Brad Spitt is no Achilles
51%Director's Cut coming!!!
41%A good addition to the epic film category
51%One of the better war movies
50%HOW DO YOU DISCRIBE EXALINTS
51%An (almost) great movie
41%Underrated: Troy is immersing and fun
40%To Pitt the best Warriors from each side is the way to battle.
31%Brad Pitt of Troy
10%Pathetic.
31%A Good Watch
31%It was not that bad
51%WOW!!! This HD-DVD is DEMO material
30%Spoiler Alrerts!
51%Troy (HD DVD Version)
51%Great MOVIE!!!
51%Achilles
51%I lived in the time of Achilles
51%Troy
30%Helen Bland.
51%Very Enjoyable
30%THIS MOVIE IS LONGER THAN THE SIEGE OF TROY
51%Excellent! Brad Pitt At His Best...
40%A Good Retelling of the Trojan War.
11%I can't get this 2 hours and 40 minutes of my life back.
51%Mythical Warriors
21%Very disappointing and without direction
51%Great HD DVD Movie
10%Terrible film.. only given a star because it looks like it cost some money
11%Torture for historians
40%"Sometimes The God's Bless You In The Morning And Curse You In The Afternoon"
51%Myth is mutable
41%Great to get, but you can't get it here
41%suprisingly good
51%Brad Pitt, best Achilles, ever! Aric Bana is a good Hector
31%Nitpicks from the windy shore of Troy (by a windy bore)
51%Highly Entertaining!
10%PUH-LEEZE.
51%An epic battle of heroes; the loss of ancient civilizations.
30%Excellent sword fights, poor screenplay. Worth seeing, though not great.
41%TROY Teems With High Adventure!
51%Much better than the reviews led me to believe!
21%Bad as a translation and bad in its own right
40%Should've Come Out In The 70s
10%This movie could've been better.....
20%Orlando Bloom go away please and never come back
10%laughable, inane travesty of homer
50%Big suprise
51%Magnifico
41%Entertaining movie, overall very well done....
41%Beware of Greeks . . . .
51%Troy
21%colossal disappointment of a DVD
50%Troy - Brad Pitt has done it again
50%old fashioned movie with new f/x "troy" is enjoyable
30%Good, but not impressive
11%I knew it would be bad, but this...
4Perfected Achilles
30%Lots of eye candy but it could've been better
21%Horrible changes to a good storyline
30%3 Stars for cinematography
30%Evokes similar emotions as The Iliad - but why change things?
30%A lot of violence and a totally misinterpreted story
40%Not Bad
41%WOW! Great movie with georgous Brad!!
50%Great history movie
50%Simply Excellent
41%Spartans 10-Troy-O (rlando)
30%There's ONE reason to see this movie
21%I really wanted to LOVE this film, BUT...
51%"Where does it end?" -- "It never ends."
11%One of Brad Pitt's worst outings
51%Where are the Oscars???
11%Letter from a blind bard
51%Historically inaccurate but a masterpiece!
40%Nothing life changing...but so what?
31%Huge potential; far from perfect realization
41%Highly entertaining
41%A Sword and Sandal Metaphor for the War on Terror
11%Read the book instead!
30%The Achilliad
40%Good visuals
51%An epic like they made in the 1950s
50%Gods and humans
51%The Trojan war on screen
3Not the definitive iliad i was hoping for
11%Yet another idiotic Hollywood epic. Terrible.
51%Troy Delivers!!
41%Historical Flop
20%Felt like Oedipus 1/2 way into it- wanted to poke my eyes out
40%Great Movie But...
21%I'll stick with the books.
50%More Gay than Gladiator
30%I like historic movies...but how truthful are they?
41%A very cool Trojan War movie! Oh, and Achilles rules!
51%Heroes and Ancient Times
30%should have been better
51%Excellent movie
31%The Pitts
10%total joto
31%Better than Alexander
31%Troy, The DVD
41%True to the spirit, if not the letter, of the original
3A fallen hero
31%What's the best way to ruin an epic? Cast Brad Pitt as the lead!
41%Grand Battle Scenes Help Mediocre Translation of Iliad
31%Tragic, because the story is still relevant to our own culture . . .
31%What on earth!
41%open your mind
51%A l;egend come to life.
10%WE HATE BIG BUDGET CHEESY, PATHETIC MOVIES
10%Garbage !
51%Engaging, entertaining, worth seeing
21%I wish I could more generous with the stars.
30%Nice for Hilywood, But not History
41%Good Adaptation
31%Ancient Battles Gap Style
10%An Epic Waste....
41%Homer Gets Colorized.
21%Where's David Lean When We Really Need Him?
30%So . . . who are we figting for again?
41%Troy earns 4 stars. . .
20%Horribly Overdone
20%Helen just left with the Trojans
41%Don't believe the critics....this is an EXCELLENT movie !!!
10%I'd give this a zero if I could
30%Pretty good, but....Brad Pitt????
31%Would it kill them to be acurate?
40%A good movie, thats all
40%Worthwhile....
40%Not bad
30%A weakened age old tale, but is it still good?
31%uneven but sometimes rewarding film
41%Forget Homer's Iliad and Enjoy the Movie.
51%Put the book aside and youll see its a good movie.
41%A Guilty Pleasure
51%A Timeless Epic of Great Heroism and Beauty
31%Lookin' for Love in All the Wrong Places
51%Exciting movie to watch....
41%Splendid effort, could have been even better
51%Hubris and Tragedy
31%Epic vision but Brad Pitt isn't good enough
40%A Good way to introduce Young Folks to the Greek Myths
21%Would-be epic misses the mark
40%Fun and Emotional
41%It was pretty good.
31%disappointing; screws over Homer's story
31%Typically Disappointing
10%What a disgrace.
51%TROY - FAR BETTER THAN GIVEN CREDIT FOR
11%The most awful movie I've seen in a long time....
31%A Mixed Bag: The Good, Bad, So-So
40%Eric Bana
31%Epic...but Brad?
31%Troy's fallen, and it can't get up
51%A good film also for classicists
41%Enjoyable realistic take of the Legend of Homer
51%enjoyable for all but die-hard Greek purists
30%Only okay- they changed the story!
41%Three hours of epic spectacle is a must-see
40%A Very Powerfull Film!
41%Not exactly the Iliad, but a pretty good movie nonetheless.
41%The story of Troy for our modern age
10%Should be called "Achilles" ...or The Brad Pitt epic
30%Disappointed with Portrayal of Achilles; Otherwise Okay
51%Good enough to watch...
30%Overrated arrogance kicks Troy right in the crotch!! (ouch!)
51%the great troy
41%Old fashioned Hollywood epic
50%This movie is so good Period.
11%Troy: Lord of the Rings, All Dried Out by a Better Writer
31%Uninspired by the Iliad
40%Good, but definatly no Braveheart.
51%A Vivid Interpretation of Homer's Epic Poem
5Troy
31%Poor reflection of Homer's Illiad of which it is based on
2A loosely movie for an epic story
3Take Immortality It'sYours- This movie may not be immortal
51%Boring reviews
5What about Achilles and Patroclus being really cousins?
20%Yawn
11%Dog Of War
31%"Beware of Greeks Bearing Gifts"
30%Troy
11%Pathetic
21% Lost in translation.
3Makes Some Excellent Computer Wallpaper
51%A very interesting screenplay
20%A disappointment
10%Horrid, horrid, horrid
51%HATS OFF TO BRAD PITT!
30%Didn't launch a thousand ships in my heart
51%Troy it, You'll Like it.
40%The less you know, the more you enjoy it
20%Boring
41%Character Review: "IS THERE NO ONE ELSE?!"
41%A lot of fun
20%Eye candy for the ladies
20%Another Braveheart/LOTR rip off
30%Neither Here Nor There
10%WHAT A WASTE OF TIME AND MONEY
51%Redefining the word "Might"
20%Tiresome and boring,..
50%This movie was sexy, romantic, and heroic.
50%Excellent
21%Definitely Not The Illiad
50%Excellent!
21%Surf's Up!
11%More vomit from Hollywood's cesspool
31%Careful boy, my mercy has limits.
20%A+B+C does not necessarily equal D in "Troy"
30%Not bad but...
30%Allow me to join the (Greek) chorus...
41%The screenplay is great, not so for the directing...
50%Awesome epic
51%Best movie of the year!
11%time lost
31%10 year war condensed to 2 hours and 42 minutes
41%if only there was intelligent life in hollywood
41%Excellent movie
11%"Anger be now your song immortal one..."
41%The Trojan War in a Nutshell
50%Saw it 3 times in one day
21%A Forgettable Epic
4Beautiful and True to the Spirit
50%Whew!
21%The ruins of Troy
40%Forget historical context. Enjoy the spectacle. Great fun!
10%Why can't I give it zero stars???
3A base hit, but no Homer
30%Greek Queens Prefer Trojans . . .
40%A good attempt.
11%Unfaithful, badly edited, and a horrible score
11%Wooden
40%Very good
51%Movie of the Year
4A Very Respectable Rendering of the Trojan War
10%Very Lame and Slow Movie!!!!!!!
41%Beautiful Brad, Bana & Bloom Beat the Crap Out of Each Other
21%Another one bites the dust.
20%Ex Oriente Lux (Light comes from the East)
41%A film for action fans, not classicists
51%Because it is possible to love both the movie AND the Iliad
31%Troy is not so bad
41%The Best Greek Epic Since "Gladiator"
41%It was better than I thought it would be.
31%Very Greecey
31%really really really REALLy looooong
21%A travesty of Greek mythology
50%Troy is the BEST!
51%Ethic wrapped in epic
11%the blind weep
41%An epic to watch without thinking too much
51%Entertaing, fun and beautiful
2Didn't like it...sorry.
50%Troy!
31%A bland, souless movie.
31%And to think, it was all over a woman . . .
20%Draining the Blood from Homer (not Simpson, that is)
41%Toiling in the Shadow of Jackson
20%A-Troy-cious!
10%bad movie, even the poor helen of troy is 1000 x better
41%Eric Bana steals the movie!
50%"I LOVE IT!!!"
31%Sheer Disappointment
31%"Troy" entertains, but there's something missing
51%Most misunderstood film of 2003
31%Better than I expected
31%A disappointemnt
31%Perhaps if Peter Jackson had directed it......
50%Entertaining Spectacle
10%a-TROY-cious
50%Get it in Widescreen
20%Troy: 50's Hollywood
51%I find it humorous...
20%worse than pittiful king arthour
41%Don't compare it to the books or plays
40%The Battle of Troy
11%Not even close
10%Gladiator wannabe
30%So-So Epic
30%Not the Iliad; but good in its own right
41%It may not be Homer, but it's good entertainment
41%Pitt and O'Toole dominate
41%Pure Entertainment!
41%Lighten up! It's a great action movie, if nothing else!
51%Surprisingly Great
51%Surprised as to how good it was
10%TROY
51%I Thought this was excellent !!!!!!
51%l_homme
41%"War is young men dying and old men talking." - Odysseus
20%Disappointed
11%a travesty of a classical story!!!!
10%The OTHER movie I stopped watching.
41%This Movie Was Surprising!
51%TROY ROCKS!!!
11%Typical Hollywood - impressive budget - no research!!
41%Even in Heavily Abridged Form, the Trojan War Entertains.
10%Wow, This movie is remarkably horrible...
51%Love this movie... however
51%Very good
51%And the OSCAR goes to.........!
40%Bana Makes this film soar!!!!
51%Just don't associate it with Homer
40%Troy
50%Great Acting
51%Way better than I expected
11%They owe me 260 minutes of my life ...
51%Breathtaking Epic that will keep you wanting more
51%AWESOME!!!!!!!!
51%Simply put EXCELLENT!!!
20%Pleasing, but not an historical account
41%An Under-rated Epic
51%Great Rendition! - The foreshadowing made me cry.
20%BUY THIS ONLY IF YOU ARE A BRAD PITT COLLECTOR:-(
31%Loved it, but also hated it
40%Call it a 4.5
31%A Mixed Bag
20%260 minutes of fluff
50%A grandiose epic!
41%Amazing action and good acting but.......
31%The woman that launched a thousand ships...and a so-so movie
21%A desecration of Homer's epics
51%Great movie
50%Enjoyable, and thoroughly EPIC
4A story worth telling in its own right....
31%Troy
41%Enjoyable Movie
50%Outstanding movie, don't listen to the "so-called critics"!
21%Troy Hollywood-style
31%Godless
41%Good film
11%Hollywood Crap
11%Even Without Desecrating Homer's Iliad, It's Just a Bad Film
40%BEST TROY MOVIE YET....FOR NOW.
51%A Grand, Exciting Epic.
2Huge, But a Disappointment...
4Troy is no Torjan Horse this movie is true Hollywood epic
41%Petersen's epic does the trick
51%Awesome movie...
31%"TROY:" NO GIFT FROM THE GODS!
51%'Alexander' Who?
4Good, but could be better
10%Inspired by Homer's "The Iliad"
51%Powerful and Stunning, All Hail Troy!
51%Grand Classic
31%i agree
41%Entertaining!
4one hell of an epic spectacular film! will become a classic.
51%A very original movie agalnst war
41%HOMER'S AN OK SCREENWRITER
10%A shame
10%Absurda
31%Some good, some bad
30%Hollywood Hash It Up
50%Reframed scene where Diane Kruger takes is off!
51%Magnificent !!!
3Ehh...
50%Fantastic
10%Loosely based in history and on Homer
51%Fantastic Movie
41%A good movie
31%Gag me.
31%Worse than the Illiad, better than Gigli...
51%The rage of Achilles - told properly
3Meets its own lowered expectations
5WOW... great epic
51%Amazed!!!
40%Penny Arcade's Review was Right!
40%Entertainment, Not History
40%Great Movie!
50%My Second Favorite Orlando Movie!
51%Troy - Don't miss this epic. It is a classic.
41%Impressive!!
51%FUN!
31%Not winning an Oscar by a long shot
50%The best
31%Hollywood (as usual)
31%Good-But disappointing
51%First film I've seen 6 times -- EVER! Truly a great film.
51%If only Homer could see this...
50%Groundbreaking
51%Brilliant
5The first real epic in a LONG time!
30%Cliche, cliche, cliche....
51%The Legend of Achilles Lives
40%This is a true example of an epic!
10%Hollywood Strikes Again!
41%Souless But Still a Grand Epic
4DVD REVIEW
51%One of the best movies ever
41%Just enjoy it for what it is...
10%All I can say is, why?
50%Troy is Great!
10%Bad on every level
10%This movie sucks!!!
10%TURKEY RIPE FOR PLUCKING
51%Fantastic Epic!
40%Praise the troy!
40%Troy
20%Peter O'Toole!
30%Homer's law-suit is still pending...
51%This Movie ROCKS!! Homer's 'Iliad' Brought To Life!!
50%Even if you hate the Dallas Cowboys...
31%Not Better than HELEN OF TROY
21%Was It Supposed To Be Funny?
51%An Epic of all measures!!!
20%A "Gladiator" Rip-Off
51%saw it twice in one weekend and it was awesome
30%Missed Opportunity
20%TROY, a comedy for the ages.
31%A Good and Entertaining Big Budget Epic
20%I Actually Expected It To Be Worse
10%Troy according to whte trash and abuser
51%One of the best films ever made.
31%Disappointing But Worth Watching
50%An Excellent Movie
50%I can't wait to get this DVD :)
51%The peace is good for the women and the weak !
30%Good date movie
51%Realistic adaptation of a classic epic....
50%Excellent Film, but Orlando Bloom rubs me wrong
10%Troy
51%The best epic in decades.
5EASILY THE BEST MOVIE EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
51%ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!!!!
51%INCREDIBLE
51%Awesome retelling of the mythological classic!
51%Makes history interesting
21%"Turn Back! Turn Back! SAVE YOURSELVES!"
51%Not based on fact, but a great movie.
41%Excellent Sword Sandal Epic
20%"I Expected Another "Ben-Hur", But I Get Trash"
11%Very disappointing...
31%Good Movie, But Some Heavy Miscasting.
51%Possibly the Best Movie Ever!!!!!
40%One of the Best Movies of the Summer
21%Hollywood Blows it big time !!!
50%Why Its Box Office Fizzled
40%A Good Solid Film
51%They DO make 'em like they used to!!!
20%Blah.....just...blah
40%What do you expect?
20%The trailer lied
40%Lots of making fan-girls happy
20%Um...
21%Egregious Epic
50%It was Troy-riffic!
31%Great to Look at, But Fatally Lacks the Emotional Punch
21%Hollywood Destroys an Epic!
40%Good movie that doesn't quite live up to epic but entertains
31%A Beautiful War
41%"This will be the greatest war the world has ever seen"
51%"Troy" marks Brad Pitt's best performance in years!!
21%Waste of time
41%SOMEWHAT CAMPY AND SLOW-BURNING, BUT QUITE WATCHABLE..
40%a beautiful but complicated movie
50%Troy is fabulous
40%Nearly Perfect Retelling of the Troy Legend...
50%Loved every minute of it!!!
50%No Achilles Heel Here.....
50%An impeccable return to the historic epic!
50%movie of the year??...quite possibly
40%One of My Favorite Stories!
41%Mixed emotions from Greece
41%O'Toole's Brilliant Performance Adds a Star
50%Heroic and Timeless
41%"Inspired by the Iliad"
51%"Inspired" is definitely an accurate description
30%Oh, what could have been.
40%Left Out Characters
21%Making a classic into something forgettable!
31%Read the Iliad instead
40%A great epic
21%Waste of Time
50%HECTOR!
40%Trojan man.
50%No, it's not about Brad
40%Troy- It's All About Brad
40%Let's drive on down to Atlanta and blow up the railhead!
50%Bravo! 2 Thumbs Up!
40%spetacular troy
2Below Average spring blockbuster
21%Where to begin?
40%TROY, though not exactly Homer, lives up to hype.
31%A plodding Greek history
41%I sing a song of sweaty men
31%TROY
31%Amusing
41%80% Enjoyable
50%Great way to start the summer
21%Iliad Lite
21%OK Action Flick...VERY loosly based on Homer
31%Eric Bana is Saving Grace of Troy
11%wait for it in the clearance bin
11%The worst film I've seen all year
40%Highly enjoyable but ...
41%Better Than I Expected
50%Excellent from Start to Finish!
31%The Fall of Troy
30%Don't expect what you read in Homer
40%Excuse me for living but I loved it!
11%And the first disappointment of the year is . . . . . .
40%There is no war that can be redeemed
21%Brad Pitt should never have been cast
31%Homer Would Disagree
41%It's definitely NOT the Pitts!
11%Bad Casting, Maudlin story, Really boring, and Inaccurate
20%TROJAN MAN!!!
11%What The #@%* Was That?!
51%An epic with muscle and heart
11%Hollywood at its Worst
41%Very Good - But Not Gladiator.
41%Very good movie, though a bit dissapointing in the story
40%The spirit of Homer, the action of "Braveheart."
50%NOW HE IS AN ACTOR!!
21%Not Very Historical
41%It is well acted but think LOTR without the care to detail
51%Spectacular
11%Homers rolling in his grave...
1Extremely bad and disappointing
21%Wait for the DVD...
21%Amazingly bad
41%Petersen's Big Fat Greek Epic
51%This film came as a shock!
41%Hollylliad
30%Troy - Movie Review
30%Meh. Not great, not bad. Just Meh.
40%good enough blockbuster
5Great movie for the summer!
31%Could have been better
11%Movie making by numbers
11%A 3-Hour Bore
30%a sometimes epic
31%Sing the Rage of Achilles
21%Messed up Homer with lousy actors
11%An Epic Cartoon
50%Troy Movie Review
3Immortality! Take it, its yours!
20%We walked out.
41%A tale for our times?
41%Troy- the antiwar version
51%Homer And Hollywood: An Epic Movie
31%Troy
11%Troy was not what it was craked up 2 be!!!!!!
31%The Trojan War -- almost
40%Very good.
50%The Best Movie of 2004 so far.
40%The Lion ,a Horse and the face that launched a 1000 ships
41%A decent adaptation for a modern audience.
51%I liked the movie a lot
31%Even with all the heroes, there's no, um...hero.
31%Brad Pitt as Achilles
11%absolutely awful
41%Brad Pitt might be Achilles but David Benioff is no Homer
11%3.5/5... were you people watching the same movie that I was?
5Spectacular
31%Troy tries to hard and fall a little short
31%You must not call it Homer
51%The Face that Launched 1,000 Ships....
30%Pretty boy extravaganza.
51%TROY is a work of art!
21%Anyone want my ticket to "Troy?" Take it, it's yours!
40%Worth the ticket price but not the Oscar
31%Obviously somebody needs a history lesson
21%Did anyone read Homer?
20%ARGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! A NOT VERY WELL MADE MOVIE!!!
4Eric Bana was memorable as Hector.
51%"May the gods keep the wolves in the hills. . ."
31%Works as entertainment, but not much else
30%hollywood summer blockbuster
31%Fun. But Brad Pitt? I love Brad, but he ain't no Achilles.
31%Entertaining Wannabe Epic Heavy on Spectacle, Light on Heart
31%Whatever good there is, it's in the story
21%Unfaithful to Homer and to History
31%Above Average Action Movie
21%Bring a pillow and a blanket!
41%Good Movie, But Too Many "Liberties" Were Taken
41%Brilliant Casting Saves Troy
41%Not perfect by any means, but still enjoyable and worthwhile
50%Very VEry good
50%TROY ROCKS!!!!!!
50%"Troy" is a masterpiece!
21%Unintentionally Campy
51%The Best Film of 2004 to date.......superb!
3Another Achilles Heel.
11%Generic
31%A costume epic that's more costume than epic
31%Flawed But Not Without Merit
5Take a trip to Troy!
2Great Classic Ruined
40%A Decent Representation Of Homer's Epic Poem
11%As the saying goes, beware of greeks bearing gifts...
51%Homer Would Be Proud
51%An Epic Adventure
50%A really riveting...and VERY political...movie!
10%Unbelievably stupid - one of the worst epics ever made
31%The Battle of the Blondes
51%Not as Good as I Hoped..but Very Entertaining!
51%Enduring Message
31%Another missed opportunity.
50%Perfect is an understatement
4Walls of Troy
31%"The Gods Envy Us..."
51%Awesome
51%One word ... awesome
20%Ponderous Bore
41%Sword & Sandal Classic gets the CGI treatment
31%Not Homer's vision but good as it is.
51%The critics are wrong...this is a great epic!
50%Initially Sceptical, but Wow. Troy Is An Original.
50%Best Movie Yet!
51%Troy
41%A Worthy Adaptation
10%Not as good as it should have been
41%A Movie That Will Appeal to Your Lust�Sexual or Blood
50%A timeless tale , a old fashioned styled epic.
50%Infor about this movie!
Review Date Rating Helpfuless Summary