Welcome, Anonymous  •  Sign In  •  Register  •  Help

Reviews: The Phantom of the Opera [HD DVD]

» Equipment » HD DVD Movies » Warner Home Video »

The Phantom of the Opera [HD DVD]
The Phantom of the Opera [HD DVD]
Other products by Warner Home Video
4.5 (1312 reviews)
Buy from Amazon
Amazon Pricing and Availability*
As of: N/A
Lowest New Price: $14.49

* Price is accurate as of the date/time indicated. Prices and product availability are subject to change. Any price displayed on the Amazon web site at the time of purchase will govern the sale of this product.
5Love it! Can't wait to get it
4As good as the play!
2If youve ever seen the Broadway performance...
4Great
5the phatom of the opera
31%Visually stunning but miscast
51%Opera house is fantastic on blu ray
5Excellent Service
50%WOW to Movie
50%My Favorite ALL TIME Movie
50%images beautifully, very well filmed
5The opera of the music lover
10%Doesnt work.
5Awesome!
5Very Provocative and Romantic!
5Phantom of the Opera
10%Poor service
50%The Phantom of the Opera
50%Music of the Night
5Truly Amazing!
4Not Just For Opera Lovers
5Phantom of the Opera - Gerard Butler
5amazing detail
5Phantom of the Opera 2004
5Best Movie of ALL TIME
5Simply, Superb !
5Loved it!
5MESMERIZING!
5Fantastic
5Buy this DVD and save your theater ticket money!
5Stunning!
5Phantom - a masterpiece!!!
10%spookykid certainly scared me!
21%Mute button operational?
31%Review from a real phanatic...
5Phantom
5One of the best musical movies
40%Beloved Musical Comes to the Big Screen
3A meteocre remake
5Phantom of the Opera
5Phantom is a must see, whether you are an opera fan or not!
5Awesome! A Must See
5I loved it!
31%Sensual Feast with Songs for a Beast
50%Beautiful film in HD
4almost excellent
51%Excellent!!!!
5Phantom of the Opera DVD
5PHANTOM
5hot and silly
5We've memorized every line!
5Book, Film, THEN Stage
5The Phantom of the Opera
55 PLUS
5Powerful!
5satified
5Musical - Phantom of the Opera
5Phanton of the opera
5Nice film version of Andrew Lloyd Webber's version
5Great movie
21%Disappointing
5The closest we will come to the Play for many of us
10%Worst Phatom they could have chosen
5show stopping service
5Phantom is Phenomenal!
5I'm in love with the Phantom
5Amazing movie
5Spectacular movie
4Pretty good
4Phantom Review
50%He's the Most Human of the Classical Monsters
10%Three hours of my life I will NEVER get back.
51%The Phantom's Spell
5Not just to watch, but to study
5Film masterpiece; definitive Phantom; true genius; classic
51%Special Features actually good!
40%The Phantom of the Opera
5Phantom of the Opera
10%No refund for a returned DVD
51%Spectacular
51%Phantom of the Opera
10%A "Masquerade" of the stage play
5Loved it!
51%Wonderful
51%Superb!!!
51%A Good, Scary Musical
50%Phantom of the Opera
51%How could I miss this???
4The Phantom of the Opera
51%fantastic soundtrack
51%We loved it!
5Phantom of the Opera
51%Stunning Blu Ray graphics, brilliant high def sound!
5Love this movie, that's it!
5The Best
40%This is some powerful stuff
5An Absolutely Amazing Movie!!
30%WOW, worth every timeless minute!
5An Outstanding Movie made better by HD DVD
51%the phantom of the opera (HD)
40%Good movie
30%audio sync issues
40%LONG LIVE THE PHANTOM----
10%Excrutiatingly bad vocals...
5This Phantom Rocks!
31%A Missed Opportunity
5A masterpiece of art
51%THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA
50%Magical play comes to life on the BIG screen
41%audio a little quite
51%A perfect film..is Beethoven in it?
5Beautiful movie
21%Ill-conceived and uneven
5Phantom of the Opera looks great on Blu Ray!
51%Phantom Movie
31%Phantom Review
10%I NEVER RECEIVED THE ITEM!
51%Must seen
51%The Phantom of the Opera
51%If I could add another three stars I would...
41%Phantom of the Opera
10%Poor -Unable to view
51%Wonderful!
41%Grand Spectacle
51%Wonderfull!!!
40%Movies
51%Holds true to the Broadway musical
51%I was enchanted
51%Phantom of the Opera
51%Movie version is a very pleasant surprise!
51%Its my favorite movie of ALL time
10%Bad storyline
51%The Phantom of the Opera
51%Best of the Best!
51%HD DVD Version
5Excellent video quality
10%If you loved it on stage...give a total miss to the movie.
31%Could have used a better phantom
50%amazing
20%Visually stunning but could have been much better
51%Captivating movie
40%Nice adaptation BUT some poor performances
51% Magical Enchantment!!!
51%Film
51%Cinematic version of Broadway musical is visually stunning and highly satisfactory...
50%Good service
41%Excellent, poignant adaptation in HD....
51%The Phantom of the Opera (Two-Disc Special Edition
51%Gorgeous
51%The Phantom comes and is beautifully displayed on HD!!!!
51%Loved it!
51%Phantom of the Opera Review
51%A perfect stage to screen adaption.
5Great Film in DVD, Greater Film in HD-DVD
51%One of the clearest HD-DVDs I have ever seen!
51%A competitor to the stage show version.......
40%Enjoyed the Movie
20%Major Problem
4The Phantom of the Opera is there, inside my mind...
4GOOD.........
51%Great musical
40%NOT as good as the opera
51%perfect....
41%Almost awesome!
51%If you love Phantom, this is a MUST HAVE
51%Awesome take on an old favorite
51%Wish I'd seen this on the big screen!
51%Love the Phantom!
51%Better than Broadway!
51%If You Can't See It On Stage, See This!
51%Enchanted by the Music of the Night
30%Phantom needs operation
51%Phantom of the Opera DVD
51%Dazzling, eye-catching beauty
20%Ouch!
20%Disappointing
4Good Movie
41%A suspenseful love triangle
20%Stage show lovers don't buy this dvd.
20%Butler Big Mistake, this is a waste of money
5loved the movie
5Great transfer
5I never stop loving this movie
51%A visual and audible experience!
51%The Phantom of the Opera
10%A Phantom of an Opera
31%Not as good as seeing the stage production, but pretty darn good
20%Dark, bad production
51%Video Quality Review (Blu-ray)
51%OUTSTANDING OPERA !
51%LOVELY!!
41%good movie of a great musical
51%JEWEL BOX OF A MUSICAL, LOADED WITH MANY CINEMATIC GEMS
51%HD DVD really shines
30%Could be better.
40%Not for little kids
4Meet the phantom!
51%Eye Candy - Love Blu Ray
5Phantom of the Opera
51%I loved it!
5Very much enjoyable
51%The Phantom of the Opera
51%Phantom of the Opera review
51%The Phantom of the Opera is here in HD-DVD
4The Phantom of the Opera
5Phantom of the Opera Review
4Excellent!
50%'Phan'tastic!
20%Nothing compared to the Broadway production.
5Fantastic Movie
5I am not dissapointed
51%Sappy but great
3Movie Magic is missing
10%Not So Good
51%EXCELLENT !
30%"The Music of the Night"...it croaks like a toad!
31%Pretty movie
51%Critics of this movie need a real job
20%Not the Phantom I fell in love with
30%Just Okay
51%Dreamlike
51%The Best Romance I've Seen in a Long Time
51%Spellbinding Operatic Masterpiece
51%I would give it 10 stars if I could!
51%cried my eyes out
50%Intensley beautiful
3Breathy, not breathless
51%Sappy and Campy
51%Outstanding!
51%Something to remember by
51%A Beautiful Production of ''The Phantom of the Opera"
51%cjmilk
4Beautiful to look at
41%Phantom of the Opera
41%Masquerade!
51%Sumptuous Musical
51%Really not enough stars for this DVD
10%phantom of the opera hd-dvd
51%Brilliant adaptation of the musical
50%Wonderful movie!
31%Worth a Look, But Definitely not Broadway
51%My tears flow at this beautiful movie
10%Piffle
41%Visually excellent. Audio? Not so much.
51%Five stars for this long-anticipated movie!!!
20%Don't waste precious time
51%Amazing Movie!
51%A testemony to the gift of creative genius
51%Phantom of the Opera
50%Better than Broadway
50%More superb than I had expected
50%Product excellent but lack basic information.
51%Love it!
51%One of the greatest film masterpieces, EVER
50%Outstanding
51%LOOK !!!!!! HD - DVD only plays on HD DVD PLayers not regular ones!!!
51%A movie musical to die for!
20%A Ghost of a Film
5Great Movie.. Great Songs.. Great Cast..
31%Finally an Onscreen Phantom
51%The Best Musical EVER!!!
51%ON A SCALE OF 1-5, I GIVE IT A 20!
51%Brava! Brava! Bravisima!
10%Kill me before I watch this again
10%GOOD TO GET THE OPPORTUNITY
51%Must See Adaptation Of The Beloved Stage Musical
5THIS MOVIE WILL BE A CLASSIC SOMEDAY!
51%Review: Phantom of the Opera
31%Boring at points?
51%2-disc special edition a great buy
51%I've read the book and
51%Does the theatrical production proud!
51%Great Story and SONGS. I WATCHED IT TWICE! IT 'S THAT GOOD!!!!!!
51%The BEST!!
51%In love with the Phantom all over again ...
51%This was an emotionally moving movie (for me).
50%Have never seen the play, but I love the movie
51%Surrender to the music of the night!
20%"Love Me, That's All I Ask Of You"
41%Great adaptation of the musical
51%Gorgeous, sensual and exquisite
51%awesome
51%Best Movie Ever Created
51%I just bought the DVD...Awesome movie!!
40%Beautiful to look at
51%This movie moved me!!!!
51%Exceptionally well done! Rivals the stage production.
51%Sizzling chemistry
10%lak zzomgggg what an amazing film!!!11!!!1!
51%~Beautiful!~
40%What a film
51%We all love it!
5Beauty Lies Iinside
51%Transfixed
5Schamucher Makes the Most of His Movie
51%Phantom of the Opera - AWESOME!
41%For a movie, it does a good job.
10%Highly disappointed
30%Movie not good enough to be ranked a five star
51% "Softee" Merry Houser
50%A Good Musical
51%Amazingly good
51%Viewed movie 23 times and cannot get enough
51%Spectacular Production
51%Frightfully Romantic
51%The Phantom Still Lives in My Heart
5Excellent
5Best musical of all time
41%Very Well Done
51%Phantom of the Opera
5The next best thing to seeing the show
51%the phantom of the opera
51%Fantastic...Fantastic...Fantastic
51%Can't get enough!
20%Andrew Lloyd Webber: Master of Broadway Kitch
51%Incredible, Beautiful, and Heartbreaking
50%A movie AS GOOD as Broadway!!
5Phantom
5Great Drama!!
5The Phantom of the Opera
50%Great
5Choose the Phantom
51%Distilling the experience
40%Weber's Phantom of the Opera
5Absolutely Beautiful!
5Phantom DVD
5One of the Greatest Movies Ever
5A wonderful move.
51%Even My Infant and Toddler Love This Movie !!
50%OH MY WORD!!!
51%Andrew Lloyd Webber's Musical of All Musicals
50%New driving music
4Almost like the broadway show
41%Good movie with a good cast except.....
51%Phantom of the Opera DVD
51%phantom of the opera
50%POTO the Best Ever
51%If you love the musical, you will love the movie
5The Phantom of the Opera (Widescreen Edition) - 2 disc
31%Flawed but still worth the price
20%Phantom
51%The Phantom of the Opera
5Great Movie!
51%A Great American Film
5Dark Side of Love
30%I love the movie...but....
30%Almost Good
51%Let me count the ways
5Terrific Entertainment
40%Sexy Phantom...
51%A wonderful version!
51%A Tour de force!
51%Obsessed with the Movie - 180 Degree Point of No Re-Turn
40%Weak Direction, Cinematography Blunts Stage Spectacular
51%Excellent
10%Worst ever!
50%Brilliant
30%A mixed blessing.
51%Phantom of the Opera (2004)
51%Riveting and emotional
51%The Phantom Of The Opera - Gerard (Gerry) Butler
51%Wonderful Twist to Original Version
51%A Gift For The Ages........
51%A visual powerhouse and a musical delight for anyone willing to give it a chance!
51%The way the Phantom should sound!
50%It takes Webber's gayest musical to gain some insight
40%Almost perfect
51%EXQUISITE! MAJESTIC! AN UNPARALLELED DELIGHT!
50%It's So Awesome.
30%Phantom of the Opera DVD
30%Phantom
51%Music Of The Night/The Phantom Of The Opera
41%Christine is A "Tease" , the Phantom A Serial Killer, But Still Good
50%PhanTASTIC!!
31%A missed opportunity and a great performance
50%Not sorry I missed the stage play...
30%Movie's okay... book is better.
40%Placer a los sentidos.
20%Beautiful movie... but HORRIBLE SINGING!
10%A promising let down
51%Stunning!!
51%Full Clip
51%I love it!
41%The Phantom movie franchise takes a musical turn
31%Ellison shines as a more "Leroux" Meg
41%Should the Phantom be so hot looking?
41%Great Film but no Chicago
51%Outstanding
51%FANTASTIC
51%Excellent
10%The Corruption of Hollywood
31%Opulent But Short-Sighted Adaptation of the Love-It-or-Hate-It Andrew Lloyd Webber Hit
51%Brilliant!
31%A Weak Screenplay
41%Spectacular
10%a movie with a lot of potential, but totally blew it in the end
51%Phantom is Phantastic!!!!!!!
51%SUPERB
51%LOVED this Movie !
51%Young woman's perspective
51%Excellent Musical Version Of The Legendary Horror
41%coulda been a contender
41%A different spin on the musical (caution-spoilers)
51%Phans will love this
10%What a Disappointment!
41%Well Pleased
51%Inspiration or Love??
50%Tragically Underrated
51%A Great Transition From Stage to Silver Screen
51%A movie even for children
41%impressively mounted adaptation
51%Very good film
50%wonderful
51%A Beautiful Film
51%Bring a box of kleenex
51%A Musical Fanatics view
31%A Different Point of View!
51%Good stuff
31%The book was, of course, much much much better...
20%But what about the TEXT?
51%No words to describe how good!!
51%Another Webber triumph
51%AWSOMENESS!!!!!
20%An unsatisfying adaptation of a good musical
51%It pulled me in
50%The Phantom of the Opera is here, inside my mind....
30%Oh woe!
51%PHANTASTIC!!!
51%It doesn't get better than this
31%Hollywood does it again!
50%Awesome
41%Great movie, awesome DVD!
51%Breathtaking, Grande!
51%Hooked on Phantom
51%Gerard Butler's Portrayal of Phantom
51%The Phantom There in My Mind
41%It wasn't perfect, but I still really liked it.
50%Bravisimo!
41%Fine Phantom Film
51%Great Movie!!!
41%The Phantom of the Opera: Lust, Pasion and Love
51%Phantom of the Opera 2 disk dvd
40%Not bad ....
5Excellent Musical
51%Fantastic Must Have
51%Caught Up
51%A masterpiece!!
51%Had me humming all day!
40%It's all about the music!!!
30%The Good, The Bad, The Indifferent
51%The Best Musical I Have Ever Seen
51%Phantom
51%The Phantom of the Opera
50%A ++++
20%Choose better singers
20%Don't confuse this with the play
50%Phatom of opera
51%I WOULD HAVE CHOSEN THE PHANTOM!!!!!!
51%Phantom of the Opera DVD Special Edition
51%Fabulous!
51%A (Hopefully) Honest Review
51%Lift your glasses in a Golden Toast to..........
41%Phantom shines on DVD
11%This movie is awful
51%The return of the Phantom
51%On stage? Breathtaking. On film? Spectacular.
51%The Phantom of the Opera
51%Great movie - awesome sound!
5Sexy Gerard Butler plays a bad boy
51%My most wonderful movie
31%visually beautiful, musically disappointing
51%Confused by all the negative reviews?
51%Phenomenal Movie!
5Worth the money
51%Lovely!
51%Wonderful!
10%All the indulgent, romance novel excess of Phanfiction without all that nasty respect for the title character
20%Disappointing singing -- and not much to make up for this
51%Angel or Phantom
30%The "Phantom" almost destory this film, like the Paris Opera house
51%Exquisite and Painfully Beautiful
50%Fantastic Rendition of Stage Play
51%Only wish i got the 2-disk set!
51%Total and Wondrous Commitment to the Romantic Vision
51%The Best Musical Ever
51%EMOTIONAL DYNAMITE AND THE BEST FILM OF 2004
41%An incredible movie that is now stuck "inside my mind"!
41%Catchy
51%BEST VERSION OF AN OLD STORY!
51%A "Must Have" for us romantics...
30%rmont
41%Everyman's Answer to this Movie
51%Sing into my Soul
10%Rate: -1000000
20%I Laughed Throughout This Movie More Than Anything...
30%Phantom of the Opera
51%Spectacular
51%Fabulous!
51%A great experience
30%THE PHANTOM of the OPERA
51%Phantabulous!!!! Must see!!!!
51%sensibility and beaty side by side
30%Much Better On Stage
41%Chicago, Moulin Rouge.... this is wher it all begun!!
10%Long, long, long!
51%Mesmerizing!
51%Phantom Movie is a Keeper
51%The Phantom of the Opera
41%Spectacular
50%Move over Michael Crawford, there's a new Phantom in town
30%Good film despite Gerard Butler
51%The Phantom of the Opera 2disc
50%A movie to watch over and over
50%A Movie for Everyone
51%Phantastic movie
5Wow. A musical I actually really enjoy.
51%A Splendid Version of Phantom of the Opera
5The Phantom of the Opera (2-Disc Special Edition)
20%Kinda blah
41%Flawed but beautiful ... like the Phantom himself
51%Lovely Goth/Romance
51%Phantom DVD Review
51%An Instant Classic!!!
51%The Phantom of the Opera
20%What the heck.?
30%Give Gerard Butler Some Singing Lessons!
51%THE BEST MOVIE EVER IN THE ENTIRE WORLD
51%WOW! is an understatment. The Phantom rocks!
51%phantom of the opera 2 disc
5One of the GREATEST movies I've EVER seen!
4Very different.... but good for what it is...
41%Almost there.
40%5 stars if you love the stage musical...
10%It is no substitute for the show!
51%Don't jump to conclusions!
51%Charmed and moved
51%WONDERFUL!!!!!!
51%Outstanding
30%Faithful to the play, but the voices are lacking
51%No meatloafs
51%The Phantom is the best
51%I love this movie very very very much
41%I was afraid to see it
10%Slowly I entered a coma
5Won't disappoint Phantom fans
31%Mixed Feelings
50%PHANTOM OF THE OPERA
51%Phantastic!
51%RAWR!
50%The movie is awesome
51%Impressive Film Interpretation
41%Phantom of the Opera
5oh my!, this is great
51%What! are you deaf?
10%The Phantom of the Opera
10%will not buy from this seller again
51%Gerard Butler is THE Phantom for ME!
51%Excellent adaptation, excellent film
41%I'm obsessed
51%Great DVD to accompany this movie-musical extraordinaire!
51%WOW - New and improved
5AWSOME MOVIES, CANT STOP WATCHING IT OVER AND OVER
51%A Magnificent Spectacle
5Best movie ever...BUYERS BEWARE
21%Disappointing
51%My first time seeing this production
51%It's one of the most beautiful movies you'll every see!
51%AMAZING!!!!!
10%What a disappointment!
51%Superb, sublime, inspiring
10%awful
51%PHANTOM OF THE OPERA IS A CLASSIC REBORN!!!!!!!
30%Not what I thought....
51%One Of The Best!!!
51%Amazing
10%Extremely disappointed
51%Phantom -- Now that's what I'd be attracted to
5Butler captivating, sexy, Webber has done well.
51%This Movie Rocks!
50%Wow!
51%WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
30%A nice film that could have been better.
51%What a wonderful, beautiful movie
21%Loved the play... not the movie, unfortunately
50%Phantom of the Opera Movie DVD
50%I loved the play and I love the movie too
20%zzzzzzzzzzzzzz
51%Superb, a sheer delight to the eye and ear
51%The Phantom of the Opera is THERE!!!
51%if you stop comparing different versions, you'll love it
10%...Only because there's no ZERO STARS option
51%A treat in every way!
51%Outstanding
10%Phantom Talent
30%On the whole, disappointing
51%Perfect to me!
51%Exquisite!
10%achoo ... [SNUFF} ... achoo - err, whoops!
51%Phantom of the Opera!! I LOVED IT!!! 5 Stars!!!!
51%Unbelievable!
51%Best Movie I've Ever Seen
30%(Mostly) Faithful, but Musically Disappointing
50%Finally a movie that does the opera justice
40%An Amazing Performance
51%Exceptional Movie
40%Goosebumps!!
10%Musicals make me ill
51%Excellent expansion of the play.
51%Haunting music and exciting movie
50%No disappointments here
50%Loved it LOVED IT LOOOOOVED IT!!!!!
50%WHY did I WAIT so LONG to see this movie!!!???
40%the phantom was toooooooo hot to be ugly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
40%Flawed, but quite possibly the finest of many adaptations
41%Don't like musicals
51%A Spectacular Cinema Extravaganza With Superb Music & Cast!
50%Two Cents
50%Awesome
51%In a Word, Sublime
20%great film but no feeling
51%Hoorah! A musical that makes musicals look good!
31%Hmm... I want to like it but not sure if I do.
10%THE SUBTITLES IN SPANISH ARE INSULTS
51%Teen Phan says "YES!"
31%High Expectations, Expectations Not Delivered
30%disappointed
40%Solid and engaging, though not spectacular
51%Enchanting
31%PHANTOM OF THE OPERA OFF-KEY
51%A Great Film Version of Phantom of the Opera Musical
30%A good try
51%Excellent, excellent portrayal.
10%disgusted from Miami Beach
51%my review for the Phantom of the Opera
40%Good movie... but...
41%Beautifully done.
10%Couldn't Even Watch it on a Dare
51%Phantom
20%...I don't get it
50%THE OPREA GHOST
20%bad bad badness
51%RJ from Blacksburg, VA
51%BRAVO
10%Horrendous
51%Phantastic!!!
50%If you love musical's you will love this movie.
51%Beautiful film, great transfer to DVD
51%Beautiful and sad!!
51%LOVED IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
51%Enchanting!
2Completely overblown and lacking in talent
51%Beautiful
10%This was B A D
50%One of the best movies i have ever seen!!!!
30%Could've Been So Much Better
51%Long wait well worth it!
10%An utterly boring disappointment
41%This Phantom Has A Message!
51%Bravo! I've watched the movie over and over again!
51%A perfect movie!
51%Spectacular
51%Absolutely breathtaking
51%Haunted by the Phantom!
51%Utter genius
41%Unwillingly pleased
51%The Angel of Music is in my mind!!!
50%ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS MOVIE
51%Loved it on the big screen, stage and on DVD
51%Wonderful--I wish I could give it more stars!
1Horrible Movie for Andrew Lloyd Webber Fans, Including Me. It Scares Me More Than Anything. I Don't Even Find it Interesting.
10%*I* didn't like it
41%The return of the Phantom
41%SURPRISINGLY GOOD!
40%MUSIC enough to chill the spine
50%COMPARED TO MOULIN ROUGE IN DESIGN
51%Not enough Hype
51%Absolutely Wonderful
30%YES AND NO
40%Surrender to the Music of the Night
50%Worth Your Time...Beautifully Done
2The Emporer"s New Clothes
41%Visually Impressive, But Not As Good as Stage Performance
30%"Phantom" a Decadent Affair of Cardboard as Well as Glamour
41%Rossum Breaks Out in a Big Way
51%Fathful adaptation, outstanding performances! Stunning!
41%A wonderful event ...
51%STUPENDOUS!
40%Stunning, But Lacking Refinement
30%Stage Presentation vs. Movie
51%One of the best movies of 2004
51%Amazing French Soundtrack Included
41%it's all in your mind
51%My NEW favorite movie of all time
51%Surprisingly splendid!!!!!!!!!!!!
51%Wonderful, spectacular
51%A very good film
41%Much better than I expected!
51%A Fantastic New Experience
41%Certainly Leaves You Singing
51%One of the most romantic films I've ever seen!!!!!
30%Disappointing
51%hauntingly beautiful...
51%Majestic Adaptation of the Musical
51%This Movie Is Perfect For POTO's Fans
40%4 stars, and here's why
20%What I Thought...
51%To correct the reviewer below
51%This Movie Is So Awesome! I Love It!!
41%Great job
51%Sorry, but I never saw it on stage...
10%What could I expect?
51%Phantom of the Opera
40%The play it wasn't
51%Mesmerizing!!!!
31%I really wish I could rate this higher...
51%Perfect Phantom for Phantom Phiends
51%All that the Phantom asked of you!
51%not perfect...but close
20%I tried to keep an open mind.
30%Missed a Great opportunity (3.5 Stars)
30%Great visuals, good music, but overall a disappointing movie
30%Still #1??
30%Outstanding Production Design
50%Amazing!
41%Is this a good movie? I think so.
51%Time Well Lost
51%Wow!!
40%The newest rock-horror musical!
51%Amazing
51%Wonderfully Seamless Transition From Stage to Screen.....
51%Extraordinary movie with spectacular acting!
20%Had excellent potential
51%A Triumph, especially for Emmy Rossum
51%A Spectacular Vision with a Soundtrack to Match!
30%2 and a half hours and it felt like it wouldn't end
51%a window into our souls
50%Worth Watching over and over again.
41%Greate Film, Bad DVD Encoding
51%Not A Mere Musical
51%This is a beautiful film
41%Passion, Sorrow, Artistry and Shirt Ruffles
51%Haunting and Romantic
4Overall, good film
51%Gerard Butler/Emmy Rossum(two revelations)
20%The difference...
51%Great Transition from the Stage to the Screen
51%Best musical movie ever
41%Great Job
51%MUSIC OF THE NIGHT
51%SUPERB DVD / Excellent BONUS FEATURES
51%OH MY GOD!!
40%Helped me put all of the pieces together
41%Aww, give it a chance
51%HAUNTING
51%PHANTOM FAN
51%Excellent Movie, Wonderful Extras
50%A Wonderful Materpiece
51%The Most Romantic Movie
40%Snazzy movie, but a lot was wrong
41%Beautiful Masterpiece
41%at least it's finally on disc
51%Bravo!
51%Phantom of the Opera. . .
20%Wonderful movie, sucky DVD.
10%Men UNITE
10%A "Phantom" Travesty
51%As if i was in the theatre again...
20%Overall Disappointing
41%A four-hankie treat
51%Fabulous movie
51%Spectacular Work of Art
41%Phantom is Solid Entertainment
30%Rossum's a knockout. But the rest of the cast...
5The Phantom of the Opera movie
50%Great movie
20%I really wanted to like this movie, but couldn't.
41%Good Film, OK DVD.
51%the best
51%Listen to the French Soundtrack as well..
20%Phamtom of the Opera
51%Better late then never
10%Major Disappointment
51%Phantom No Menace on DVD
51%Carried away by "The Music Of The Night"! (revised)
51%Musical to Movie
20%Good Grief
51%How do you do it Andrew!?!
51%Open Up Your Mind and Enjoy
51%What movies are all about!
51%Wow! Blew My Socks Off!
10%A note...
51%Total Entertainment !!!!
41%Good movie, terrible sound
51%"The Phantom Of The Opera" is impressive!
41%POTO - Almost Amazing
51%It's a wonderful movie!
51%Outstanding Story of Unrequited Love and Manipulation
51%Great Gift! Loved it!
51%A Theatrical Masterpiece
30%For what this movie is, IT'S EMBARRASSING!
20%Who on earth cast Gerard Butler??!!
51%GERARD BUTLER, THE MAN, THE MASTERPIECE!
51%Brilliant version of Lloyd Webber's best loved musical.
51%A "Must See" for fans of the Broadway show
10%Didn't want to hate it!
51%THE BEST MUSICAL IN YEARS
51%As good as a Movie can be!
51%A Classic Musical; One in a Million
51%Phantastic!
10%A disaster beyond your imagination
20%what a horrible musical!!!
51%A Total Masterpiece!
51%The Phantom is greatest movie i ve seen in a while
51%HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
51%Not the play and just as good
31%A mixed treat
20%What is everyone thinking?
41%Brilliant adaptation, beautiful story
51%Lovely to Look At
51%Excellent Flim But.....!!!!!
41%I thoroughly enjoyed this movie
50%One of the best movies I have ever seen
51%Watch it more than once
51%Romantic drama lives on - A truly beautiful piece of art
51%Spectacular!
40%Think Moulin Rouge.... but much better.
41%Open your mind; it's very good for what it is!
41%Take it from a trained musician....
20%Oh, dear ...
51%The Best Phantom Yet - Surpasses Stage Production & B&W Film
30%"Help me make the music of the night!"
51%sparkling screen incarnation of Lloyd Webber's PHANTOM
51%Love the film. That's all I ask of you.
20%Phantom
51%You have to look with better eyes than that.....
50%The Best Movie Ever!!!
51%TOTALLY AWESOME!!!!!!!
51%A hauntingly beautiful work
51%If you hate musicals you will still like this one.
51%The Phantom is Phantastic!
10%Disaster From the Start
50%Please read this
51%Best movie of all time...in every way
51%really beautiful film
51%Best Show Ever!
20%Is this a film?
51%Great Movie!
51%phantom of the opera mpvie rocks.
50%The Phantom of the Opera
51%Don't say the stage play was better!
51%Glorious
51%See it on the big screen
51%Amazing!
51%Stupid to Listen to Negative Reviews
40%"Phantom of the Opera" OMP is decent...
51%Feast for your Eyes
51%The Most Beautiful And Tragic Film
51%You'll love this movie
51%THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA IS THERE INSIDE MY MIND...
51%MY GOD, WHAT A VISION
30%Not good. Not bad.
51%I was overwhelmed
41%Phantom Review
51%Unbelievable
51%WOW
41%I absolutely LOVED this movie but...
51%Truly fantastic
51%A Grand Show of Emotion and Love
31%A sometimes pretty & somtimes bland soap Opera
51%simply awe-inspiring
51%This movie is a jewel
41%Brilliant (4 1/2*)
40%Sublime
51%Don't listen to the Critics
51%If you miss this, you miss a classic.....!!!
51%AMAZING! Why didn't this get nominated for picture?
40%COLLOSSAL
20%Not as good as seeing it in theatres.
51%The best movie in the world
51%Music Of The Night
41%Delighted
51%SUPERLATIVE
51%Exceptional viewing experience; pleasure for the eyes/ears
51%The New & Hotter Phantom
41%Oh my word...
51%The Greatest Motion Picture of All Time
51%the best musical ever on film
40%Acting Great Directing Bad
50%Absolutely Wonderful
51%One For The Senses!!!!
51%The Phantom in all of us.
51%For the past 3 years these things do happen.
51%Fantastic
51%Phantom Phan
51%The Best Musical i've seen
40%Wonderful except for 10 minutes
30%Phantom review
51%POTO is beyond good.
51%AND I SAW THE MOVIE AND IT WAS GOOD
41%Beautiful
51%Perfection! Pure Beauty!
51%Emmy Rossum, Gerad Butler and Patrick Wilson Shine!
51%This movie is wonderful! It brought tears to my eyes!
51%Must See!
51%Phantastic Phullfilled Phelling Phor Phavorite Phantom Philm
51%My favorite movie musical ever!
40%Beutifully done!
51%Outstanding
10%A Phantom To Phorever Phorget
10%See the Show - Don't buy the movie
10%Miserable
51%Pure Spectacle!
51%Excellent Adaptation!
30%Just like any ALW, the stars are the sets.
41%Mixed reaction in theater, but I loved it
51%Stupendous!
51%Phantom of the Opera is fantastic
51%Cannot really compare the movie to the stage play
51%Must buy this DVD
51%I loved it!
51%PHANTastic...a MUST see!
51%A Message to Gerard Butler & Cast of The Phantom
51%Breathtaking and a Delight to See
51%One of my favorite movies!!
30%Gerard who?
50%The Amazing Phantom of the Opera
51%Everything I expected and more!
51%The Phantom of the Opera
51%Wonderful
51%Beautiful
40%Gorgeous. Now listen to me.
51%My honest opinion
40%The Phantom of the Opera
51%Phantom - movie, was extraordinary !!!!!
51%A wonderful production
51%ABSOLUTELY ASTOUNDING!!!!!
51%A Delightful Surprise
51%My favorite movie of all time
51%Emma
51%Pure heaven! The best movie experience I have ever had!
51%I was surprised
10%Should never had been made.
50%By Far Surpasses Even the Play!!!
30%Pretty to look at, but that's all
51%Wonderful, Oscar-Worthy! GREAT CAST!
5hear it, feel it, secretly possess you
40%Good but can't beat stage production...
51%I absolutely love this movie
51%See "Phantom" Despite the Film Critics...
51%Beautiful
51%the phantom of the opera 2005
5Gerard Butler IS the Phantom
51%I'm Glad I Just Saw "Phantom" Before It Leaves Theaters!
51%Hauntingly beautiful...
51%Absolutely amazing!!!
51%For the romantic- no matter what age
51%See the movie, buy the DVD
51%Amazing
51%This movie moved me like none other.
51%The Phantom of the Opera 2004
51%Fall in love with the movie...see it
51%Sexy, Amazing & entertaining
51%Great Film - Best Phantom Ever!
51%"Phantom" should have been an Oscar nominee
51%Blew me away!
51%Fall in love all over again
51%The movie totally rocked!
51%Seductive ... Captivating ... The Phantom soars!!
20%The Best Picture? Please...give me a break
51%a greatb broadway show got 10 times better on film!
51%Escape For 2 hours and 25 minutes
51%What a feast!
51%Start a journey through a strange new world
51%Truly mesmerizing
51%AMAZING!
51%Stunning, Beautiful Rendition Of A Classical Masterpiece
51%Phantom of the Opera
41%Really Good
50%A WONDERFUL MOVIE FOR PHANTOM!!
41%This stage production fan loved it!
51%Amazing
51%Don't let the critics fool you!
51%Addictive
51%absolutely fabulous
51%MAKE THAT 10 STARS !!!
51%I Love this Movie!
51%A darker side for the Phantom!
50%Great movie
30%"It's over now the music of the night."
51%Fantastic Movie!
51%wonderful film
30%Big and Beautiful....with some flaws
51%Astonishing
51%Excellent Movie!
30%I LOVED this movie but....
51%Sexy Phantom = Excellent movie!
30%Webber's Masterpiece Finally On Film
51%Phantom 's True Love
51%Something for Everyone
51%The Phantom of the Opera is inside my mind....
31%I'm torn!
51%I'm addicted...
51%One of the best movies!!!!!!!
10%I don't even know where to begin...
51%Phantom of The Opera
51%Beautiful and unforgettable
5I LOVE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
40%Nothing psychotherapy and plastic surgery can't fix
51%It Was An Awesome Movie!!!
51%Entrancing!
51%Mesmerizing Film - Gerard Butler is the "Phantom"
20%Greatly Disappointed
51%GERARD BUTLER / OUTSTANDING ACTOR / GREAT MOVIE
30%The Phantom of the Opera
51%The BEST ever.
51% I was ENTHRALLED AND UNDRER ERIK'S SPELL............
51%Phantastic!
51%The Phantom is AMAZING!
51%Absolutely beautiful!!!
41%Flawed, But Grandeur of the Images and Sound Overwhelms You
51%Bravisima
51%Phantastic Work
51%Most Romantic Movie Ever!
51%*sings* I'm under his spell..........
51%Great Movie
51%The phantom of the opera is there... inside my mind
41%Think of Me.
30%See it, but bring a caffeinated beverage.
51%Can't get enough!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
20%Phantom - good, bad and very ugly
31%Worth seeing, I guess
51%Amazing
51%Absolutely wonderful!!!
51%I have a question
51%Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
51%Awsome movie
51%Darn Good
51%MUST SEE!
51%Absolutely lovely.
51%Make up your own mind!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
51%Please go and see!
51% What movie did the critics see?
51%Phantom of the Opera is the best movie I have ever seen
40%Must Choose Between Mr. Nice Guy And The Bad Boy
51%The Best of the Best
51%What a Spectacle!
50%I'd Give It 6 Stars, If i Could...
51%Phantom of the Opera
20%Beautiful sets, terrible singing
51%Brava, Brava, Bravissima!
51%Not as Good As the Play, but still amazing
51%best field trip ever
51%The "Best Romantic Movie" of 2005
51%Great Music and fantastic cast of acting
51%Don't miss this in the theaters
51%A Great Evening!!
51%More Than a Musical or Musical Theatre
51%Tremulous and Tender
51%Movie Magic
51%Beautiful
51%Overwhelmingly Magnificent!
51%Went in with low expectations, never so happy to be wrong!
51%Best Movie Ever!
41%Almost perfect!
10%Wait for the DVD if you must see it
51%THE MAGIC OF THE PHANTOM
30%How can you compare this film to the stage? No comparison!
51%Wonderful Movie
41%Eye candy set to music
51%The Phantom on the Big Screen was Fabulous!!
51%Gerard Butler - My Mom's New Male Fascination
51%beautiful musical with talented actors
20%NOT SO GREAT
51%The Phantom of the Opera movie
40%Close enough
51%YOU MUST SEE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
41%Mediocre music, but opulent, and then there's Gerard Butler!
50%Amazing story
51%Highly recommended for all musical lovers
20%As a Musical ...
51%Mesmerizing!
50%One Of The Greatest Musicals Of All Time!! Right With "F.L."
51%AMAZING!!!
20%The near miss of the music of the night.
50%I loved it!
41%Un-biased and educated review
41%Visually Stunning, but...
51%Absolutely Amazing
51%Excellent
5 a feast for the heart and soul
51%Beautiful Phantom
51%breathtaking!!!!!!!!!!!!! well worth the wait!!!!!!!!!
51%If you liked the stage show, you'll love the movie
51%The best Movie EVER!!!
51%Phantom of the Opera
41%Phantom of the Opera - Could have been better !
51%Best film of the year!
5Phantom Fantastic!
51%Beautiful, Passionate - Wow!
5Absolutely Fantastic!
40%Don't Miss It
2OH MY
30%Phantom or not....
51%WOW! What a visual, audio and sensual feast !!!
51%Simply fantastic!
51%Unexpected Splendor
5Bravo
51%Spectacular Candy for the Eye and Ear
41%Movie Of The Year
51%Fantastic Movie
51%Face the music. The Phantom will take your breath away.
51%Phantom of the Opera
51%The word "BEAUTIFUL" finally comes out of my mouth!
51%Amazing adaptation from Broadway
51%Excellent, Loved this film, better than the stage
51%WONDERFUL!!!!!!!!
51%Just Beautiful!!!!! I was Floored!!!!!!!
51%Phantom Steals Hearts
41%Emmy Rossum...who could ask for more!?
51%The one of the Best Movies I have ever seen!!!!!
51% Great and Amazing
10%Well, Joel Shumacher is back to directing crap...
51%Phantom was wonderful in so many ways....
51%Different - Not better or worse, but different
5Loved, loved, loved this film!
41%Gorgeous Faberge Egg But Empty When Opened
51%A MUST TO SEE!!!!
50%I Have Seen the Movie (and have seen the play 4 times).
3Good version--could have been great
51%Better than the Broadway Show
51%Perfect!
40%Good enough! :-)
30%Not bad... but not terribly good either.
51%Spectacular!
51%PERFECT, 5++++++++
40%Odd Choices
51%Beautiful Transformation
5Magnificent
41%reality based movie v. credulous magic
5Awesome movie!! Great move from play to flim!!
41%Trust in Webber
51%The Phantom of the Opera (movie) was EXCELLENT
51%Gorgeous and Magical
5Phantastic!!
41%Powerful movie, but different emphasies than stage play.
30%Hit and miss
10%How to Wreck a Classic
5Mesmerizing, wonderful
51%Beautiful and haunting.....A must see!
51%The Phantom Will Win Your Heart
51%The best movie probably you will ever see
51%Very Pleased
30%Disappointing Phantom that doesn't live up to the hype
10%Phantom of the Flop-era
51%Awesome and Beautiful
51%What a hottie
30%something of a bore, but Rossum was fantastic
51%I'm a beliver.....
51%"He's here. The Phantom of the Opera..."
51%Wonderful, Beautiful. Must see movie!
51%Amazing!
41%Phantom Haunted Reviewer with Emotions.
51%Stands on its own merit
51%Great Movie, Great Music
51%Beautiful
51%AWESOME, BREATHTAKING, SHOULD BE 5 ++ STARS
41%Shockingly Acceptable
51%LOVED IT!
10%Ham is always served best on stage
51%Even Better than Broadway
41%This Film DOES NOT disappoint
51%AMAZING!!!!!!!
51%very nice : - D
51%Loved It
51%An Angel of Music Has Been Sent
51%Awesome! Wonderful! Loved it! Will see it AGAIN!!
30%Eh.....
51%Brilliant
51%Great adaptation of the stage classic
20%Very Disappointing.
51%PHANTOM is a solid and spectacular film musical
51%A New Phan!
51%Come to me, my angel of music...
51%amazing
51%Worthy Effort
10%Batman and Robin director ruins yet another movie....
41%Visual Delight
41%Loved it!
51%WOW....
51%My New Favorite Movie of All Time
51%YES BEST MOVIE EVER
51%Beautiful movie
51%Seen it twice already...
51%Let the dream begin...
51%Surrender yourself to the music, elaborate sets, and cast!
41%Let the dream begin?
51% You can't miss this
51%Saw it this afternoon with my wife
10%Schumacher didn't get it.
51%Just like sitting in a Broadway theater seat
51%Standing ovation
51%One of the best movies I've ever seen
51%Awesome Movie for Phantom or Musical Fans
51%Fabulous
51%Excellent Movie
51%It's like a Dream of Romantic...
51%Awesome
51%Do yourself a favor and watch it
30%Tacky and disappointing
50%Phantom of The Opera
51%A Masterpiece Of Grandeur and Opulence
41%Another pleased Lloyd Webber fan
30%The phantom menace
51%The Phantom of the Opera
30%Beautifully done, vocally distraught
51%Just give it up
30%Why?
50%I am without words...okay, maybe not.. 5++++++++ STARS!!
51%Lloyd Webber's Phantom movie is an orgy of opulence
30%Not a clue......
51%PPL PLEASE
51%Emmy Rossum is a rare find
51%Test Screeners Give Phantom TWO THUMBS WAY UP!!
51%Phantom convert to screen
30%Mixed feelings
30%Questionable Phantom
51%I HAVE SEEN IT!!!
51%The Masquerade Begins December 25th
50%great idea
51%Gerard Butler as Phantom
51%Webber's Phantom Comes To the Silver Screen
Review Date Rating Helpfuless Summary